NTSB issues final report on FIU bridge collapse, makes safety recommendations

The report reiterates what the agency already announced in a recent public meeting about the determined cause of the bridge's collapse

November 19, 2019
NTSB FIU pedestrian bridge collapse final report
Image: NTSB final report, taken from FIU video camera

The National Transportation Safety Board (NTSB) recently released its final report on the Florida International University (FIU) pedestrian bridge collapse that took place in March 2018.

The report reiterates what the NTSB already announced in a recent public meeting about the determined cause of the bridge's collapse, along with safety recommendations from the agency to the Federal Highway Administration (FHWA), the Florida DOT (FDOT), the American Association of State Highway and Transportation Officials (AASHTO), and FIGG Bridge Engineers Inc. (the designer of the bridge).

The NTSB says its investigation focused on the following safety issues: bridge design and construction plan errors, and unique bridge characteristics and mechanisms of failure; independent peer review of complex bridge design; shortcomings in oversight of evaluation of and response to significant observed bridge structure distress prior to collapse; and lack of redundancy guidelines in specifications for pedestrian and concrete truss bridges.

The agency had announced at its meeting that the probable cause of the collapse was the load and capacity calculation errors made by FIGG in its design of the main span truss member 11/12 nodal region and connection to the bridge deck. In addition, the agency determined that inadequate peer review by Louis Berger contributed to the collapse. The report also says the severity of the collapse—which led to the deaths of six people—was due to the failure of multiple contractors and agencies—including FDOT—to cease bridge work when cracking in the structure had reached "unacceptable" levels and to take appropriate action to close down SW 8th Street in order to protect the public.

Towards the end of the final report, the NTSB makes several safety recommendations, most of which were for FDOT. This included the recommendation that FDOT revise its Plans Preparation Manual to require that the qualified independent peer review for category 2 bridge structures include checking and verifying the design calculations used for all nodal forces. It also recommended procedural implementations to specify that when structural cracks are initially detected during bridge construction, that the parties responsible for the bridge work immediately close the bridge to construction personnel and close the roadway underneath it as well as restrict pedestrian and vehicular traffic on the bridge itself. 

In a concurring statement regarding the findings of the investigation, NTSB Vice Chairman Bruce Landsberg noted that this event would serve as a landmark case study for years with engineering schools. "The bridge was not properly designed, and there was no qualified oversight on that design," Landsberg said in his statement. "Once the cracking became evident, not one of the organizations involved was willing to take the essential and unpopular step to call a halt and close the road."

The entire report, including Landsberg's statement, can be viewed on the NTSB website.

------

SOURCE: NTSB

Related Articles

Gov. Mario M. Cuomo Bridge in New York; 2020 Prize Bridge Awards
The Gov. Mario M. Cuomo Bridge in New York was one of the major spans recognized in the 2020 Prize Bridge Awards. Image: New York State Thruway Authority
The American Institute of Steel Construction (AISC) and the National Steel Bridge Alliance (NSBA) recently announced the winners of the 2020 Prize…
February 21, 2020
Marc Basnight Bridge, Dare County, North Carolina
The Marc Basnight Bridge in North Carolina won the Main Span more than 150 ft award in the transportation category. Image: PCI
The Precast/Prestressed Concrete Institute (PCI) recently announced its annual PCI Design Awards for 2020.  Judges awarded 25 projects and five…
February 06, 2020
Gov. Hogan announces Chesapeake Bay Bridge completion for summer 2020
Gov. Hogan announces Chesapeake Bay Bridge completion for summer 2020. Image: Office of Gov. Hogan
Gov. Larry Hogan this week announced that all lanes at the Chesapeake Bay Bridge in Maryland will be open this summer as deck work on the westbound…
January 30, 2020
The Texas DOT (TxDOT) recently announced that FIGG Bridge engineers—the design firm that worked on the collapsed FIU pedestrian bridge—is being…
January 14, 2020
expand_less