NO. 1 BRIDGE: Bayonne Bridge

This behemoth riveted through steel truss arch structure wows its way to the top of the list

(This feature published as "Riveting Work" in November 2019 issue)

Brian W. Budzynski / November 05, 2019
NO. 1 BRIDGE: Bayonne Bridge
The Bayonne Bridge project provided nearly 1,500 jobs annually throughout construction, an estimated $380 million in wages and $1.6 billion in economic impact for the region.
Everybody loves a big-ticket bridge build.

Even folks who have no real appreciation for structural engineering or the complex geometry at play in the design and erection of a bridge can still find some measure of wonder and awe at the sight of such an undertaking. For those of us close enough to this industry to appreciate the finer details, the Bayonne Bridge is no less impressive. 

Once the longest steel arch bridge in the world, the Bayonne Bridge had, of late, threatened to restrict trade to the Eastern Seaboard’s busiest container ports. With the expansion of the Panama Canal and the introduction of new “Panamax” shipping vessels—too large for the bridge’s existing 151-ft clearance—the Port Authority of New York & New Jersey and design team HDR/WSP sought to raise the bridge to a 215-ft clearance. Rehabilitation and preservation was expected to cost half as much as the build of a new bridge and to shorten the timeline by seven years. Furthermore, the team kept the design and historical significance of the Bayonne Bridge, while extending its life by 100 years.

The original roadway system that carried one lane of traffic in each direction was kept in place during construction, while a new elevated roadway system to carry two lanes of traffic in each direction was built. The new roadway was constructed 64 ft above the existing roadway, raising the clearance level as required. The sequencing was based on using a transfer girder to remove the existing floor beam’s wire rope suspenders and transfer the suspender support forces to adjacent floor beams. Once the existing suspender was removed, the new floor beam was erected at the new, elevated level and supported by new suspenders anchored in the bottom chord. Temporary suspenders were then installed from the bottom of the new floor beam to the existing floor beam. After which, lateral bracing for the new floor beam was installed along with the stringers of the new floor system. The support force in the transfer girders was then transferred to the temporary suspenders. The force in the temporary suspenders was adjusted to verify that the pre-operation elevations of the existing deck were reconstituted. The transfer girders were then disengaged and advanced to the next panel point, and the entire process was repeated. The operation was repeated 21 times.

The Bayonne Bridge carries nearly 3.5 million vehicles annually, and the residents of Staten Island could neither afford nor would they stand for a complete shutdown of the bridge. The Bayonne is one of only four bridges that provide egress from Staten Island. What’s more, an estimated 4 million 20-ft equivalent units (TEUs, a standard shipping container) pass beneath the structure annually. These goods are vital to the region’s economy; their passage could not be constrained by construction. Closing the bridge or infringing upon the shipping channel was simply not an option.

A new bridge on a parallel alignment was not feasible, as it would have required the acquisition of numerous properties, which would have triggered the need for an environmental impact statement, a minimum four-year process. By designing the project within the confines of the existing right-of-way, the Port Authority used an environmental assessment which only took eight months to approve, thus providing an accelerated timeline. 

The increase in navigational height necessitated new approaches to be constructed in stages to allow uninterrupted local traffic flow. First, the northbound approach structure and elevated roadway on the arch were constructed. New pier columns were erected through the existing deck to stay within the right-of-way. Then the existing southbound structure was demolished after traffic was moved off the existing bridge on to the new northbound structure. Then the new southbound structure was constructed.

The increase in navigational height necessitated new approaches to be constructed in stages
The increase in navigational height necessitated new approaches to be constructed in stages to allow uninterrupted local traffic flow. The existing southbound structure was demolished after traffic was moved off the existing bridge on to the new northbound structure after its construction. Then the new southbound structure was constructed.

Designing the new approach superstructures included four separate segmental concrete box girder bridges with a total length of more than 10,600 linear ft. The span lengths for the two side-by-side structures vary from 125 ft to 272 ft. The box girders were built using a self-launching, overhead gantry truss, while the approach bridges were built with segmental cantilever construction to eliminate the need for falsework and to allow the bridges to be constructed over traffic and existing structures. The approach bridges include a 36-ft-wide roadway that increases to 48-ft-wide at the abutments to accommodate acceleration and deceleration lanes. The southbound structure is designed to accommodate future light rail on the west overhang. The northbound structure includes a 12-ft-wide shared-use path on the east overhang. The two structures also carry a fire standpipe, drainage, and 38 other miscellaneous utilities enclosed within the boxes.

The roadway was widened to four 12-ft lanes with a concrete median barrier and 5-ft shoulders compared to the original roadway of 10-ft lanes with no median barrier or shoulders. 

The design team developed a concept that permitted new floor system construction above the existing floor, allowing one lane of traffic in each direction to flow during peak hours. With additional weight on the structure and increased wind loads, the team added more than 4,000 tons of steel plates to strengthen the arch. The strengthening design methodology, certified by Purdue University’s Bowen Laboratory, brought the bridge into compliance with AASHTO LRFD requirements. More than 100,000 rivets were replaced with high-strength bolts as part of the strengthening process.

The project provided nearly 1,500 jobs annually throughout construction—an estimated $380 million in wages and $1.6 billion in economic impact for the region. The previous roadway discharged untreated stormwater directly into the Kill Van Kull waterway. Drainage improvements eliminated these discharges by collecting and routing water for treatment—removing 80% of suspended solids and 40% of pollutants. The waterway and bridge are also possible breeding locations for more than 70 bird species, including the state-listed endangered Peregrine Falcon. As such, the team, with New York State Department of Environmental Conservation, New York City Department of Environmental Protection, and New Jersey Department of Environmental Protection wildlife biologists, made significant efforts to protect fowl habitats. Removing half the approach span piers improved air, light, and viewing conditions, and allowed parks and waterfront access.

The project also included fully automated tolling, a fire suppression system, new mechanical and electrical buildings on each shoreline, aesthetic lighting, security enhancements, and a bridge health monitoring system.

When asked about how this six-year endeavor finally closed out, HDR/WSP Lead Engineer Joseph LoBuono, P.E., told Roads & Bridges: “This has been the project of a lifetime. I have been involved from the initial feasibility phase through to the completion of construction. Strong partnership of Port Authority staff and the consultant designers made this project happen. It has been an honor to work on a project designed by the legendary engineer Othmar Ammann and to perform our work to extend the life of his work for another 100 years—while bringing it up to current codes.”

Project: Bayonne Bridge 
Location: Staten Island, New York & Bayonne, New Jersey
Owners: Port Authority of New York & New Jersey
Designers: HDR and WSP
Contractors: Skanska-Koch/Kiewit
Cost: $1.08 billion ($180 million for arch)
Length: 7,160 ft (structure); 10,991 ft total
Completion Date: February 11, 2019

About the Author

Budzynski is senior managing editor of Roads & Bridges.

Related Articles

NO. 2 BRIDGE: Marc Basnight Bridge (Herbert C. Bonner Bridge replacement)
One challenging aspect of the project was working in a sensitive marine environment. The project footprint is home to 20 protected species; the north end of the bridge lands in the Cape Hatteras National Seashore, while the south end lands in the Pea Island National Wildlife Refuge. Several innovative solutions were employed to ensure environmental impacts were minimized.
From the time the Herbert C. Bonner Bridge was built in 1963 over the Oregon Inlet along the North Carolina coast, the structure was in trouble.…
November 05, 2019
NO. 3 BRIDGE: 41st Street Pedestrian Bridge
The city of Chicago has seen a boom of dynamic architectural development in the last 15 years, and the new 41st Street Bridge, which was designed by architects at Cordogan, Clark & Associates, serves as yet another jewel in the Windy City crown.
Through an international design competition called “Bridging the Drive,” the City of Chicago constructed a new signature pedestrian bridge at 41st…
November 05, 2019
NO. 4 BRIDGE: Lesner Bridge
The city had decided early on that they wanted a segmental bridge in order to have longer spans, more curves on the structure, and an aesthetic quality that would fit the bridge into the landscape. One of the factors that was considered in the design phase of the project was to create more space between the pier columns in order to provide unobstructed views of the Chesapeake Bay and Lynnhaven River.
Anyone traversing the area of the Lynnhaven Inlet along Virginia’s southern coast at nighttime would be remiss if they failed to notice the dazzling…
November 05, 2019
NO. 5 BRIDGE: Champ Clark Bridge over the Mississippi River (U.S. Hwy 54)
The new bridge was opened Aug. 3 to much public fanfare. The great grandchildren of Champ Clark himself were on hand for the opening, along with 600 other people. The demo of the old structure was underway as of this writing, with deck removal complete.
Originally completed in 1928, the Champ Clark Bridge—so named for a former Missouri Speaker of the House—stood as a landmark along the Mississippi…
November 05, 2019